Crave Online


MaxTV Podcasts Fight Schedule Radio Todays Press Message Boards Login
Max Analysis
John Raspanti
Radio Rahim
Radio Rahimn's Interviews Radio Rahim's Facebook Radio Rahim's Google+ Radio Rahim's Website email Radio Rahim


Luis Cortes Archive


Alec Kohut Archive


Marty Mulcahey Archive


Allan Scotto Archive


Stephen Tobey Archive


German Villasenor Archive


Anson Wainwright Archive


Matthew Paras Archive


Daniel Kravetz Archive


Jason Gonzalez Archive

The 2011 Preview Review: Part Two

In Part One of the annual Preview Review, I lamented how journalists making predictions for 2012 are certain in the knowledge that few readers remember what they penned 365 days ago. To write for Maxboxing is to be held to a higher standard. To that end, I venture back in time to review my predictions for the year of 2011. Again, I encourage readers to take a look around the ‘Net. I don’t think you will find another sports website or publication taking the time to analyze its editorials from the past year.  
In Part Two, I revisit predictions from featherweight to junior middleweight, examining my picks for a champion who will stay, a champion who will go and a boxer to watch out for. I do not make any changes to the 2011 predictions, removing the temptation to make myself look better through minor or subtle removal of erroneous or irrelevant content. That forces me to separate this feature into three parts in order to keep the word count below that of a Stephen King novel. At the end of each prediction, I apply a simple grade, from A to F, along with an opinion on how the prognostication turned out. 

Champion who will stay: Hozumi Hasegawa – A positive for this pick is that Hasegawa is out of the mix for a big featherweight showdown this year since few are aware of him in America. That is a negative for fans and a shame since Hasegawa has the talent to push Yuriorkis Gamboa and Juan Manuel Lopez to the limit. There is an outside shot of a fight materializing with Chris John in late 2011, which would be an easy sell in Asia. Mandatory contender Jhonny Gonzalez must be dealt with and that is my main concern. However, Gonzalez will have to travel to Japan for that fight and his performances have been erratic over the last two years. At age 30, Hasegawa is slowing but he remains sharp and still has key advantages of being a southpaw and fighting at home. 
Grade – F: Age and Jhonny Gonzalez caught up with Hasegawa, as the Mexican took Hasegawa’s crown via fourth round knockout last April. The proud Japanese champion has not given up the fight and was scheduled to fight undefeated Mexican prospect Felipe Felix before an injury scuttled his return. Remains a viable threat everyone at featherweight and frankly, should be rated in the top 10 by The Ring magazine. 
Champion who will go: Yuriorkis Gamboa – Most will disagree with this choice but I am playing the odds more than denigrating Gamboa. If the Juan Manuel Lopez fight takes place, I believe Lopez has the right combination of attitude and skills to defeat Gamboa. Other than his next fight against Willie Casey, Gamboa will have a difficult schedule to traverse in 2011. Having said that, I doubt any of the four titlists lose their crowns in 2011 since the Gamboa – Lopez fight will not get made until early 2012. That leaves Gamboa with potential fights against Chris John and perhaps Elio Rojas, both difficult bouts which he could lose, given those champions’ qualities. On top of all that, Mikey Garcia (featured below) is the number one-rated challenger, who has the potential of breaking through to elite status as Abner Mares did last year. 
Grade – B: I obviously rethought my opinion about “JuanMa” beating Gamboa but the Cuban lost his WBA strap during the course of the year and now fights above the 126 pound limit. Because of this, I give myself a B instead of an A since Gamboa never lost an actual fight. 
Will rise in 2011: Mikey Garcia – One of boxing’s overlooked feel-good stories, Garcia is a dedicated boxer in the ring who graduated from the Ventura County Police Academy. Has a great team around him, starting with undervalued trainer and older brother Robert Garcia. Oxnard product has lived the game and seems to have innate sense of the ring. Was 58-7 as an amateur despite using the bouts to further his pro potential and style instead of hunting for national tourney successes. There is nothing mousy about this kid, once he throws punches and showed a ton of maturity in outboxing former title challenger Walter Estrada, despite breaking a finger early in that fight, and stopped ten of his last 11 opponents. Mature beyond his years, often sparring with Israel Vazquez and displayed real stopping power in his right hand. Garcia is still developing a ring persona but has shown the ability and diversity to beat opponents with speed, power or movement. Thailand’s Chonlatarn Piriyapinyo was considered but I could not find enough video footage to evaluate him. Matt Remillard and Jorge Diaz drew my attention but fell short in quality wins when compared with Garcia. 
Grade – B+: Could have easily given myself an A since Garcia’s three victories were breathtaking in their effective destructiveness. I thought the level of competition could have been better, so I slightly downgraded Garcia. Given Garcia’s performances and the promotional backing of Top Rank, he is certain to get a title shot in 2012. I believe there is a chance Garcia can develop into a special fighter in the mold of an Alexis Arguello. 
Champion who will stay: Takahiro Ao – Edges Mzonke Fana on the strength of his overall ability; I only considered Fana because he does not have a mandatory contender this year and is only likely to fight once in 2011. Ao is a skilled southpaw, working with a hometown advantage, who is less likely to get upset than the 37-year-old Fana. Ao has a tough mandatory with slick Belarus boxer Sergey Gulyakevich but their styles will neutralize each other and I suspect Ao gets the benefit of the doubt in Japan. Ao has improved since his loss to Elio Rojas and at age 26, is entering his physical prime to go along with a mental maturing in the ring. Ao has only lost or drawn with championship quality boxers and I doubt he runs into one of those this year. 
Grade – A- : Made two successful defenses of his title but neither did much to elevate Ao’s reputation, given the ordinary opposition. The Gulyakevich bout never materialized and Ao had a tough time with pesky Italian Devis Boschiero that ended in a split decision win for the hometown favorite. Probably the weakest of the alphabet champions but because of experience, toughness and sound chin, will be difficult to unseat. 
Champion who will go: Takashi Uchiyama – I rate Ricky Burns and Mzonke Fana weaker champions but Uchiyama has to get by tough countryman Takashi Miura at the end of month. After that, Jorge Solis looms as the number one contender, who will probably be paid step-aside money so Jorge Linares can challenge Uchiyama. Linares is more popular in Japan, having fought there many times, and is a superior boxer to Uchiyama in every category. Uchiyama is a good boxer but lacks the ring generalship of potential rivals and is slowing at age 31. The Miura fight will prepare and strengthen Uchiyama for a possible showdown with Linares but not enough to forge a victory. 
Grade – F: Uchiyama looked fantastic defeating Miura and knocked out veteran Jorge Solis last week showing no signs of aging or weakness. Given a bout with Linares is not likely to materialize now, Uchiyama could add two more title defenses and take his current streak to six. Uchiyama’s 32 years of age remains a concern and a title unification with Takahiro Ao makes sense for both men. If that fight happens, do not look for Uchiyama to be my pick to lose his title in 2012.  
Will rise in 2011: Adrien Broner – Beats out Cuban Luis Franco on youth and has more upside, even though his boxing IQ is not on par with Franco’s. Cincinnati has produced great fighters like Aaron Pryor, Freddie Miller, Ezzard Charles and Tim Austin; now Adrien Broner looks to add his name to that roster of greats. Started boxing at age ten and was a good junior-level boxer, winning the national Silver Gloves tourney and advanced to the semifinals of the Junior Olympics. That type of success eluded Broner at the senior amateur level tourneys but Dan Rafael reported Broner had about 300 amateur bouts. Is a speed-burner in the ring with excellent defensive reflexes and has shown an ability to use that speed on offense, knocking out 15 of 18 opponents. A bit of a peacock in the ring, whose assuredness pays off for fans as Broner takes chances to make himself look as impressive as possible. That cockiness can rub people the wrong way but it certainly adds flair and extra attention to a fighter who could get lost in the crowd, given Golden Boy’s large stable of boxers. Can’t emphasize enough how much speed is a part of Broner’s success. I hope to see Broner use angles and jab more to help himself as he matures and inevitably meets someone equally fast. Reminds me a bit of James Kirkland in his aggressive nature but without Kirkland’s physical strength. Will Tomlinson and Luis Cruz were also considered. 
Grade – A- : Bounced back from a bad performance against Daniel Ponce De Leon, a controversial unanimous decision win the WBO title. Broner’s technique and confidence improves with every fight and his upside is recognized by television networks. One round blowout of Jason Litzau was the highlight of 2011, displaying the combination of speed and power that made Cincinnati boxers of the past famous. I am not a big fan of the whole hair-combing shtick (not sure what that is about) but otherwise, Broner shows himself capable of competing with the elite at 130 pounds. 
Champion who will stay: Humberto Soto – I appreciate Soto more than most but admit he can be negative, taking away an opponent’s best weapon instead of pressing his own advantages. Despite his being older, I believe Soto has more room to improve on his performance against Urbano Antillon when they rematch in May. Theirs was a classic fight, garnering many votes for “Fight of the Year” with Soto engaging Antillon instead of outboxing the naturally bigger man. Soto fights more than most champions, four times last year, but I believe he will slow the pace since his paydays are likely to be larger. I would not be surprised if number one challenger Antonio DeMarco is his only other fight in 2011. Has only been outclassed once, by Juan Guzman, and, at age 30, sports the right combination of experience and vitality to reign another year. 
Grade – D : Much anticipated rematch with Antillon never materialized but weight-making difficulties compelled Soto to fight at junior welterweight twice last year. This forced Soto to relinquish his title and drive my grade down to a D, given “La Zorrita” did not actually lose his title in the ring. 
Champion who will go: Juan Manuel Marquez - I would not be shocked if every lightweight champion lost his title in 2011 since Miguel Vazquez has seemingly fought above his station in boxing. I chose Marquez because he is likely to be stripped of the WBC or WBA title for not facing their mandatory contenders. Number one contenders Robert Guerrero and Brandon Rios do not carry the kind of cache- Rios less than Guerrero- nor provide the payday to entice Marquez into a fight. Because of that, Marquez will have to relinquish a title and, to be truthful, I would not be surprised if Guerrero beat Marquez straight up anyway. Either way, Marquez leaves 2011 with one less title belt around his waist. 
Grade – B+ : Not sure what grade to give myself. Both of Marquez’s fight in 2011 were above lightweight and no one is sure Marquez can make the 135-pound weight limit anymore at age 38. Given the crappy alphabet bandits hand out multiple title belts in one division, Marquez still owns a version of the WBO and WBA title (Robert Guerrero and Richard Abril are other types of “champions”) despite not defending them in over a year. 
Will rise in 2011: Leonardo Zappavigna - Comparisons will be drawn between Leonardo Zappavigna and Kostya Tszyu for more than a shared hairstyle. But they have a different attacking philosophy and a better style comparison can be made to Zappavigna and fellow Aussie Michael Katsidis. Where Tszyu was a selective destroyer, making every punch count like a bazooka, Zappavigna swarms with machine gun flurries. Displays power in both hands and the 23-year-old should improve as the maturing process impacts his strength and mind. Stylistically, Zappavigna seems easy to categorize at first glance but has underlying skills that are not seen in YouTube knockout compilations. Mostly a volume puncher who could be called a brawler, if it were not for clever footwork coming forward. Commits to his punches more than the average volume guy but does not limit himself in the body attack the way pure power-punchers do. Is a big junior welterweight with a lot of his bulk centered on broad shoulders (is shaped like Kermit Cintron). A big right hand is Zappavigna‘s coup de grâce of choice. Zappavigna knocked out iron-chinned Ji Hoon Kim, in his last fight, to announce his arrival on the world stage. Fellow youngsters Sharif Bogere, Mercito Gesta and legally-troubled Archie Ray Marquez are runners-up. 
Grade – F- : “Zappa” got a title shot in 2011 but was completely outclassed by Miguel Vazquez, showing a lack of versatility and speed against the tricky champion. Tough fights could have already caught up with Zappavigna, as he suffered a shock kayo at the hands of Ameth Diaz in his next fight. At 24, is young enough to recover but lacks the all-around game to beat quality opponents when his power is not enough. I should have gone with second choice Sharif Bogere, who, unlike Zappavigna, finds different ways to win fights. 
Champion who will stay: Amir Khan – Came of age in his fight with Marcos Maidana despite boxing stupidly to please his fans and shut up detractors. The result was a thrilling fight but also displayed why Khan remains vulnerable against brawlers and elite boxers. Khan took himself out of the running for a fight with Manny Pacquiao and is not likely to face the Tim Bradley - Devon Alexander winner until early 2012. Another reason to select him is trainer Freddie Roach, as Khan will continue to improve under his direction and as lead sparring partner for Manny Pacquiao. Victor Ortiz and Brunet Zamora are his top-rated challengers but look for him to batter a domestic British challengers and Zab Judah this year instead. There is an outside chance of a date with the resurgent Erik Morales or maybe even Marquez, if he feels like stepping up in weight again. All are winnable propositions. 
Grade – F : Action-packed wins over Marcos Maidana and Zab Judah announced Khan’s arrival on the elite stage in 2011. However, the multitude of punches Khan absorbed in those fights, combined with the Anthony Peterson setback, shows Khan lacks the defense to topple the very best. Much of the goodwill Khan has built has been erased by the way he and his team cried (about bad officiating when the fight should not have been so close) in the aftermath of his loss to Peterson. It has turned many off on the usually affable Brit. Now, Khan must reverse his loss to Peterson and defeat Tim Bradley on top of that just to get back to where he was only one month ago. 
Champion who will go: Devon Alexander – Since there is no IBF champ and I picked Khan to remain a champion, I am left to fill this spot with the man who I believe will lose the Tim Bradley – Devon Alexander showdown on the 29th. Enough said. 
Grade – A : Looked out of his depth dealing with incessant pressure of Tim Bradley, losing a wide decision in a cut-shortened bout. Most believe Alexander got a gift decision in his next fight against Argentine Lucas Matthysse, where consistent pressure got to Alexander again. Those fights have chased Alexander out of the division as the St. Louis native has decided to move up in weight and compete at welterweight. 
Will rise in 2011: Danny Garcia - One of Golden Boy Promotions’ earliest East Coast signings, Garcia had been making impressive progress, fighting almost exclusively on West Coast shows. Returned to Philadelphia to score an impressive kayo against Mexican banger Enrique Colin on the Bernard Hopkins-Enrique Ornelas undercard and has a knack for delivering his best work when TV’s spotlight shines on him. Garcia’s boxing skills were instilled at the amateur level, a 107-13 record, winning a national Golden Gloves title and topping out as an Olympic alternate. Growing up in the tough Philly gym system will serve him as well, if not better, in the pros as his time with the national amateur team did. Garcia has really quick hands and his feet keep him in continual contact with the target. I would not qualify Garcia as a strong puncher but his punches land with sudden authority and make a solid popping sound. Needs to work on keeping the hands up but not at the expense of his aggressiveness. Displays good head movement and reflexes but because he is usually moving forward, was not tested defensively. That was until Ashley Theophane found some holes but Garcia worked to correct those flaws in the gym. The better level of competition focused Garcia, as he improved despite the heightened threat level. The 21-year-old is more mature and calm in the ring than most boxers at this stage of their careers. There is good depth at 140 and this choice was difficult. Mike Dallas, Ajose Olusegun, Paul McCloskey, Ruslan Provodnikov and Cesar Cuenca all lacked one or more of the combined qualities of Garcia to beat him out. 
Grade – A- : Philadelphian proved he is a legitimate contender by defeating former champions Kendall Holt and Nate Campbell, not looking flustered or confused by anything the veterans threw at him. Is scheduled to fight Erik Morales in March for the WBC title, making my choice for the champion who will go in 2012 much easier. 
Champion who will stay: Manny Pacquiao – Do I need to explain? He is Manny Pacquiao! There is no one within ten pounds of “Pac-Man,” up or down, that I can see the Filipino icon losing to including Floyd Mayweather. It’s that simple. 
Grade – A : Well, for many, the “victory” over Juan Manuel Marquez (I thought Pacquiao edged it) casts doubts over the Filipino’s ability to defeat Mayweather. I believe Marquez just has the style to give Pacquiao fits, the way a Ken Norton did Muhammad Ali, and if they fought 100 times, all would end in close decisions. In the end, Pacquiao kept his title and I keep my “A.”
Champion who will go: Jan Zaveck – I toyed with the idea of selecting Andre Berto, as I think Selcuk Aydin has the tools to beat him and I continue to believe Berto is not yet a finished product. However, playing the odds, I picked Zaveck because he is more prone to lose, given his age and weaknesses as a champion. Now that I got that out of the way; I think every welterweight champ keeps his title through a combination of weak challengers and lack of money and interest to match them against another. Do fights between Vyacheslav Senchenko, Andre Berto, and Jan Zaveck send your senses racing? Not mine either, which is why each will reign over his little kingdom in the shadow of “Pac-Land.” 
Grade – A : I found myself rooting against this pick, as the personable and hard-charging Zaveck showed tons of heart and willingness to engage in his TKO loss to Andre Berto. Zaveck was coming on and had his moments in the Berto fight but his right eye closed, forcing a stoppage to the entertaining brawl. Despite his 35 years of age, Zaveck remains a top ten fighter in the division and showed me enough (and, I hope, executives at HBO) to advocate a return to American television in 2012. 
Will rise in 2011: Brad Solomon – I admire this Solomon, who is becoming a contender the old-fashioned way. I liken him to a young James Toney and Glen Johnson, since he uses old-school tricks and methods to get ahead. Won seven fights last year, including successful trips to Nicaragua and Panama, and defeated an Anges Adjaho few voluntarily fight. Was brought in as an opponent to undefeated prospects Ray Robinson and Kenny Galarza, on ESPN shows, but quickly turned the tables on both, scoring lopsided wins. Solomon was an excellent amateur, who won three Golden Gloves titles which shows in his ability to switch from orthodox to southpaw in a split-second. Defeated current hot Golden Boy Promotions prospect Danny Garcia in the amateurs, suggesting he has ample speed and confidence. Solomon showed he can bring those elite amateur credentials to bear on a pro platform, no matter the country or opponent. At 27, is fully matured physically, and has been busy logging six fights in 2009 and seven more in 2010. I am concerned that Solomon is too willing to take chances in scheduling and could run into another quality fighter instead of avoiding him. Selcuk Aydin, Kell Brook, and Mike Alvarado were considered but lack Solomon’s ambition, given that he has not been a pro for three years yet.
Grade – B+ : Put himself in line for a WBA title shot in 2012 with a wide ten-round decision over Demetrius Hopkins. However, that was his only victory in 2011 (Solomon averaged seven fights in the previous two years) and there are rumors of managerial problems that could tie up a title opportunity in courtrooms. Too bad since Solomon is a tricky operator and deserving of a title shot based on combined wins over the last three years. 
Champion who will stay: Miguel Cotto – Considered selecting Pacquiao again, since there is no way Golden Boy will rush their number one prospect Saul Alvarez into facing “Pacageddon.” Alvarez is the WBC’s number one contender for Pacquiao but Oscar De La Hoya is happy to have Alvarez hold the phony “silver” title until Pacquiao is quietly stripped or elevated to some bogus status by Jose Sulaiman. That leaves Cotto (who has already been passed over for another shot at Pacquiao), who faces recently resurrected Ricardo Mayorga in March. Rigoberto Alvarez is the mandatory for Cotto and that fight should find its way onto some PPV undercard to fill out the Puerto Rican’s dance card for the year. There is also a possibility Bob Arum decides to cash out on Julio Cesar Chavez Jr., which would be a preferable payday to Alvarez for Cotto and equally winnable. 
Grade – A : Many thought this choice foolish; Cotto was seen as “damaged goods” and on the downside of his career, given the hard fights on his boxing odometer. I credit new trainer Pedro Diaz for getting Cotto on his toes and focusing on defense, bringing Cotto back to what he was as a promising prospect. In those days, Cotto was an all-around boxer with heavy hands and, at age 31, Cotto can emulate Marco Antonio Barrera’s late career change from slugger to boxer. 
Champion who will go: Cornelius Bundrage – I admire “K9” Bundrage for his dogged determination but his skill level is simply not that of a world champion. Bundrage did sneak up on an aging and disinterested Cory Spinks last year but does not have the wherewithal to deal with elite challengers like Vanes Martirosyan or Erislandy Lara. I do not consider Bundrage’s mandatory, Sechew Powell, elite but I think Powell has the skill set to defeat Bundrage as well. Bundrage is 37 years old but in fantastic shape in every department except reflexes and has been out of action since winning the title five months ago. Does not have a fight schedule, suffering from Don King’s lack of TV dates, so it is a combination of factors that lead me to pick against one of the better success stories of 2010. I hope I am wrong selecting Bundrage and will root against this pick in 2011.
Grade – D : I should know better than to pick a Don King fighter, since they only fight once a year! Bundrage is a good boxer, though you wouldn’t know it since he only fought once each in 2009, 2010, and now 2011. Yes, this sounds like sour grapes but I can’t give myself an F when the only fighter Bundrage defeated in 2011 was Sechew Powell. In 2007 and 2008, Bundrage fought more three times, and in each year, he lost once. At age 38, Bundrage is a good pick to lose his title in 2012…if he fights.
Will rise in 2011: Erislandy Lara -  The busy Lara is on cable TV more than Billy Blanks infomercials, fighting eight times in 2009 and five times in 2010 (an ESPN favorite). This  Cuban has avoided the dreaded “lackadaisical” tag from trainers and garnered a lot of praise for wins over Grady Brewer and Danny Perez. To avoid the pitfalls of other Cuban boxers based in Miami, Lara leaves the city to train under the tutelage of Ronnie Shields in Houston. The impressive junior middleweight (promoted by Germany’s Arena-Box) is a three-time Cuban and one-time world amateur champion that was favored to make an Olympic appearance before his defection. Showed some one-punch kayo power since turning pro and earned a good reputation in sparring sessions against Ricky Hatton. A mature 27 years old, Lara’s power and amateur pedigree suggest he will have little problems when the level of opposition is advanced further. A well-rounded southpaw, I would not classify him a great puncher since he does not look for power from the opening bell. He is not a speed merchant either; I would call Lara cunningly fast and exceedingly accurate. Lacks the flash, brilliant hand speed, and power of fellow Cuban Yuriorkis Gamboa- or the cocky persona, for that matter. Is a controlling boxer.

Grade – C : Again, I find this hard to grade. Lara did officially lose his fight against Paul Williams but the large majority of journalists and fans judged him the winner. However, many thought Lara struggled against rugged Carlos Molina, scored a draw, making it difficult to give him more than an average grade. Lara certainly passed tough tests and, given the quality of opposition, I decided to round up, giving Lara a solid C. 
In Part Three, I review middleweight through heavyweight.
You can contact Marty at or visit him at

Subscribe to feed Subscribe to feed

© 2010 MaxBoxing UK Ltd