Crave Online


MaxTV Podcasts Fight Schedule Radio Todays Press Message Boards Login
Max Analysis
John Raspanti
Radio Rahim
Radio Rahimn's Interviews Radio Rahim's Facebook Radio Rahim's Google+ Radio Rahim's Website email Radio Rahim


Luis Cortes Archive


Alec Kohut Archive


Marty Mulcahey Archive


Allan Scotto Archive


Stephen Tobey Archive


German Villasenor Archive


Anson Wainwright Archive


Matthew Paras Archive


Daniel Kravetz Archive


Jason Gonzalez Archive

The 2011 Preview Review: Part One

It is time for the year-end ritual of analyzing my 2011 Preview, an annual act that fluctuates wildly between self-abuse and narcissism. Visitors to other boxing websites are sure to notice how easy it is for writers to make predictions for the New Year, certain in the knowledge that few will remember what they wrote a year from now. Here at Maxboxing, we have higher standards and are held accountable for what is published. With those thoughts in mind, I venture back in time to review my predictions for the previous year. Take a look around the ‘Net; I don’t think you will find another website or publication doing the same. A shame really, since journalists should be like the boxers we cover and learn from past mistakes while expounding on positives.

In the 2011 Preview Review, I revisit my predictions in every weight class for a champion who will stay, a champion who will go and a boxer to watch out for. I do not make any changes to the predictions from last year thus removing any temptation to make myself look better through the removal of erroneous or irrelevant content. That forces me to separate this feature into three parts in order to keep the word count below that of a J.R.R. Tolkien novel. At the end of each prediction, I apply a simple grade, from A to F, along with an opinion on how the prognostication turned out.


Champion who will stay: Nkosinathi Joyi – The 27-year-old IBF champ is a beast, rocketing up the rankings last year to become the number one strawweight on The Ring magazine’s and most other unbiased observers’ ratings. I had him at number four at the beginning of 2010 and one dramatic win was enough for Joyi to take over the top spot. Handed undefeated Mexican Raul Garcia a lopsided beating to earn that distinction and is likely to get his title defenses at home in South Africa. The only problem I have with Joyi is a lack of ring appearances, fighting four times in three years, but for purposes of keeping his title, that is a good thing for this category. Still, it is a shame he has not fought more often since Joyi is a real joy to watch operate in the ring.

Grade- A-: Ring activity continues to be a concern for the talented Joyi and is why I give the lowest A possible. Only fought once in 2011, retaining his title in an anti-climactic three-round no-contest with top ten-rated Katsunari Takayama. The fight was too short to reveal anything substantial about either boxer. The pair fight a rematch in March, so I might just stick with the same prediction for champion who will stay at strawweight this year.

Champion who will go: Donnie Nietes- For my 2010 preview, I picked Nietes as “the champ who will go” but I hope Nietes plays nice this time and loses a split decision instead of keeping his title another year. It’s not that I do not like or enjoy watching Nietes but because he is not a champion who attracts a lot of fan support, he must face popular boxers on the road. In fact, Kwanthai Sithmorseng is the weaker reigning titlist but will not have to face an interim champ like Nietes who is likely to be forced to travel in order to defend his crown. Sometime in 2011, Nietes will pack his bags for Mexico and face Raul Garcia or be stripped of his title, which I believe will mark the end of his quality reign.

Grade – A-: Nietes did not lose a fight in 2011 but I was still right since The Filipino moved up in weight to avoid a mandatory defense against Raul Garcia. Two months ago, Nietes defeated Ramon Hirales to win the WBO junior flyweight title, making Nietes my frontrunner “Champion to Go” in that division this year.

Will rise in 2011: Kazuto Ioka – Talk about ambitious, this 21-year-old and his team are challenging undefeated Oleydong Sithsamerchai (34-0 and rated number two in the division by The Ring) in February despite only engaging in six professional bouts! Ioka grew up in boxing; his uncle Hiroki Ioka was a champion in the late 1980s and he amassed a 95-10 (64 wins of which were stoppages) amateur record winning eight national titles. In his fourth bout, against average trial horse Heri Amol, Ioka was knocked down by a right hand but got up late in the count to finish the round, otherwise dominating the fight. In his last outing, outboxed skillful southpaw Masayoshi Segawa, stopping him on cuts in the tenth round. At 5’5”, has good size for the division and uses it particularly well on defense, circling from the outside, looking for openings. Is lightning-fast and counterpunched one-time contender Takashi Kunishige out of his shoes in only his fourth fight. Is moving down in weight for this opportunity, having fought at 107 or above for all his fights, so Ioka should enter as the bigger and stronger man. If he can maintain 105 pounds - and a win is not a given against the quality champ he faces - Ioka could be a monster at the weight.

Grade – A+ : Ioka impressively destroyed Oleydong Sithsamerchai viva fifth round stoppage to win the title and showed versatility in a 12-round title defense against hardnosed Mexican Juan Hernandez. Ioka makes a voluntary defense on December 31st but regardless of outcome, has earned this grade for 2012. This kid could be special!


Champion who will stay: Giovani Segura – A rematch with Ivan Calderon is possible for mid-year but that should not bother fans of Segura since he is improving while Calderon ages. I do have two concerns selecting Segura, the first is that he likes to be active, which should lead to four fights-per-year at minimum and more opportunities for an upset. The other factor is that Segura had two non-title bouts where he scaled four and five pounds above the junior flyweight limit and that weight fluctuation can catch up with someone at age 28. Aside from that, Segura should run roughshod over the division, which sports good but not great challengers to his throne. Potential challengers are likely to go after the weaker champions as well, with only the experience of Omar Nino and versatility of Brian Viloria as possible threats. If Segura does not wander up in weight for bigger paydays, I can’t see him losing.

Grade – D- : Did not give myself an F because I stated the possibility of Segura moving up in weight and also mentioned the man (Brian Viloria) who knocked Segura out when he moved up in weight two weeks ago. Segura also scored a second stoppage of Ivan Calderon out their rematch, showing he is still the best junior flyweight in the world. Don’t write Segura off since he is an exciting fighter whose style and work ethic demand title shots in the future.

Champion who will go: Gilberto Keb Baas – Wisely overpriced himself out of a fight in Japan against young phenom Kazuto Ioka but I doubt Bass can avoid the challenge of countryman Omar Nino for a calendar year. Baas unexpectedly dethroned Nino, via majority decision in November, and the WBC is likely to force a rematch, given its track record of favoring bigger attractions. I admire Baas’ activity, six fights in 2009, but question the wisdom of that, given his 33 years of age and over 400 rounds of boxing on his odometer. Baas can still school upcoming youngsters but I doubt he can overcome a return engagement with Nino or a trip to Japan to meet one of their veterans. Baas is an admirable boxer but will return to the status of high-level gatekeeper in 2011.

Grade – A : Baas lost his title in April; a cut and bad swelling suffered against Adrian Hernandez forced the ringside doctor to stop the fight. Baas was losing on the scorecards and had a point deducted for low blows but showed a ton of heart in the face of Hernandez’s relentless aggression. At 34, Baas is on the downside of his career but is the type of threat a promising upstart needs to beat to earn a title shot.

Will rise in 2011: Ryo Miyazaki – Edges out South African Hekkie Budler (whom I am more familiar with) because Miyazaki has not struggled in steps up in competition and shows more versatility on defense. This despite Miyazaki’s three draws, in fights that ended before the fourth round, and facing a less divergent set of styles. In Miyazaki’s last fight, against former title challenger Junichi Ebisuoka, he overcame a nasty cut to stop his challenger and dealt well with the blood. Gets great sparring with gym mate Kazuto Ioka and had a decent 40-4 amateur career to which he was introduced after a stint at a youth correctional facility. Is on the right life track now and has good mix of speed and power (right hand is the finisher). Still relies too much on physical gifts and needs to add a consistent jab and better footwork to his arsenal. Often boxes with feral abandon, which has resulted in Miyazaki receiving cuts from headbutts, leading to three draws. At 5’1”, is even short for this division but was doing well despite a five-inch height deficit against Suguru Takizawa before a cut forced a draw stoppage. Is poised for a title shot, ranked in the top 11 by all four sanctioning bodies, but I would prefer one more year of seasoning before challenging any of the champs except Gilberto Keb Baas.

Grade – B : Miyazaki got the year of seasoning I advocated, winning three fights and retaining the important OPBF title. A coveted belt, since owning the OPBF strap almost inevitably leads to a WBC title shot. I could justify an A- grade but his level of competition actually regressed in 2011, forcing me to downgrade Miyazaki’s mark.


Champion who will stay: Moruti Mthalane – I chose Mthalane because of circumstances rather than any superiority I see in him over the other three titlists. The South African is not the most skillful of the foursome but I doubt Mthalane fights more than twice this year and the IBF does not have a number one contender to face. This leaves Mthalane and his advisor to their devices, cherry-picking a South African and probably a beatable Argentine to square off against in 2011. I was shocked at how easily Mthalane dispatched of Zolani Tete last year, so even if a viable challenge emerges within the IBF top ten, he has a good chance of repelling it. Two losses have come via kayo, so there is a chance Mthalane runs into a punch but, again, his handlers are not likely to schedule a big puncher when not forced to do so.

Grade – A : South African knocked out two title challengers, the diverse Johnriel Casimero and Andrea Sarritzu, and looked better than I expected doing so. Remains number four on The Ring’s rankings in a talent laden division, which features  Pongsaklek Wonjongkam, Brian Viloria, and streaking Hernan Marquez. At 29, Mthalane is near his prime, and with more experience (to protect that questionable chin) becomes harder to dethrone.

Champion who will go: Daiki Kameda – I do not think Kameda will lose in 2011 but doubt the brash youngster can make the 112-pound weight limit for another year. If he does, Kameda will certainly be weight drained and susceptible to a quality challenger like “interim” WBA champion Luis Concepcion. Kameda got a gift decision (as respected Hall of Fame journalist Joe Koizumi reported) on Sunday against volume-punching Hungarian Silvio Olteanu, which should convince him to move up a division. That would be lucky for me, as I see all four champions retaining their belts through a combination of weak challengers and few ring appearances. Kameda has toughest mandatory in Luis Concepcion (unless Giovani Segura moves up in weight), which is the impetus for this choice. Julio Cesar Miranda will likely be forced to face Brian Viloria this year but I have grown tired of trying to figure out which Viloria will show up for a fight.

Grade – A : I had to wait to the last minute but Kameda was upset by unheralded Thai Tepparith Kokietgym three weeks ago by decision in Japan. Team Kameda cited weight making difficulty as a factor in the loss but I am not proud and will take an A grade any way I can get it.

Will rise in 2011: Milan Melindo – Turned pro at age 17 and put in good work to win 23 fights at age 22. Boxing purists will find much to enjoy with Melindo - he only has a 30% kayo ratio stopping seven foes - who darts in and out of skirmishes like a Miguel Canto wannabe. First strapped on a pair of gloves at age six, using the sport to educate himself, graduating high school, thanks to a boxing scholarship. Speed and timing make Melindo dangerous but an ability to stay in the pocket and use his left hook is what catches the eyes’ attention. Best win came over former IBF champ Muhammad Rachman, admittedly past his prime, whom Melindo circled and beat to the punch, scoring a unanimous decision. In his last fight, widely outpointed former champion Carlos Tamara and showed a sturdy chin when tagged on a couple occasions. Though he does not score many stoppages, Melindo stuns and puts opponents on the canvas. That lack of killer instinct or finishing ability is a concern at the highest level, as is his only having fought once outside of the Philippines (in Dubai). The Tamara and Rachman wins show Melindo is ready for a title attempt and, as a top ten-rated challenger in the IBF and WBA, that could come to fruition this year. I also considered Liverpool’s Paul Edwards and American Austreberto Juarez (born in Mexico) who both had excellent amateur careers but both lack the number of fights to properly evaluate them.

Grade – B- : I am disappointed Melindo only registered two wins this year. Raised my grade from a C+ to B-, since Melindo was recognized by others in 2011 and is now rated in the top 10 by The Ring magazine. Takes on hard-punching former title challenger Juan Esquer in January, which I hope indicates a heavier workload, leading to a title shot in late 2012.


Champion who will stay: Omar Narvaez – I was burned by Narvaez before, reluctantly picking him as the “champ who will go” back in 2007. Light-punching Jose Cabrera is his mandatory, who does not have the pull to bring the fight to Mexico, which is his only chance of victory. This Argentine stylist continues to be extremely underrated; the first class of 2000 Olympians to win a professional world title, Narvaez has yet to lose as a pro, while racking up 16 title defenses. In his last fight, Narvaez won the WBO junior bantamweight title (now a two-division titlist) and, at age 35, shows little signs of wear and tear. Excellent in every aspect of the game, Narvaez is slowly inching his way into territory held by the likes Nicolino Locche, Pascual Perez and the legendary Carlos Monzon in Argentina. In years to come, Narvaez will probably be seen as one of the most undervalued champions of his generation.

Grade – A - : Yes, Narvaez looked bad (offensively) losing a fight against P4P entrant Nonito Donaire; but that was at bantamweight and even in a loss, Narvaez showed some brilliant in the pocket countering instincts early. Argentine remained dominant at 115 pounds repelling three challengers including highly-rated Cesar Seda. So, I reluctantly hand out an A- grade for the work Narvaez did in his natural weight class.

Champion who will go: Tomas Rojas – Makes a return to Japan in February, where he withstood a final-round knockdown to defeat capable Kohei Kono to win the vacant WBC title. This time, Rojas faces a more powerful punching former champion Nobuo Nashiro, who is not even the mandatory challenger to Rojas. So if Rojas defeats Nashiro, which I doubt he will, equally dangerous countryman Juan Montes awaits him late in 2011. The 30-year-old Mexican southpaw is a good overall boxer but both Montes and Nashiro have speed and age advantages to exploit. Rojas can be bullied, as stoppages by Vic Darchinyan and Jorge Arce (body shot) show and never defeated a fighter who was a champion. I still view Rojas as one of boxing’s better gatekeepers, using his elongated body and jab to constantly pester opponents with voluminous punching. At the elite level, however, he will need more than one great tool to survive.

Grade – A : Rojas surprised me by beating Nashiro in Japan and impressively defeated countryman Juan Montes in a real brawl three months later. Rojas could not duplicate his road victory though, losing to unknown Suriyan Sor Rungvisai in Thailand. I viewed nine of those 12 rounds on YouTube and the unanimous nod for the hometown hero seems a correct verdict. Overall- and despite Rojas losing his title belt- I am more impressed with Rojas at the end of 2011 then I was entering it.

Will rise in 2011: Cesar Seda – Puerto Rican southpaw sports a tantalizing combination of power and speed, not lacking the courage to risk his chin to employ those assets either. In two of his last three fights, defeated underrated veterans Jose Lopez (despite an injured knuckle) and Daniel Reyes, showing he can deal with experience in brilliant fashion. At 24, is entering his physical prime, and it is now time for Seda to now show he can conquer another young gun like himself. Is cocksure, calling out Ivan Calderon when he had no résumé to do so, and has the reputation of a trash talker as well as being a diva in the gym. At 5’6”, has great size and uses it well, flicking out a blinding jab before moving his fast feet to set up combinations. 15 kayos in 20 bouts is the result of speed over power but can Seda can stun anyone with one shot? His follow-ups need to be more controlled and a better punch selection is called for, given his relaxed manner in the ring. Uses reflexes instead of form on defense but is competent and has a good amateur career behind him as well. One concern could be that Seda is trained by his father, which has caused problems in the past. Moved up to junior bantamweight last year and handled the weight well, though he did only compete in two fights. Is shooting at Hugo Cazares (negotiations were made but broke down three months ago for a February clash) and, entering his sixth year as a pro, it looks like this is the make-or-break year for Seda.

Grade – C- : I obviously had no idea Seda’s management was in negotiations with Omar Narvaez, whom I selected to keep his title in 2011. I would not have selected Seda as my boxer to rise in 2011 if I had known there was a possibility he would challenge one of the best, in my eyes, and underrated champions of the last ten years in Omar Narvaez. Having said that, Seda had his moments against Narvaez and the experience of challenging Narvaez in Argentina will help Seda win a title in his native Puerto Rico in the near future. I did not give Seda an F or D, since his ambition (challenging Narvaez in Argentina) does not deserve a failing grade.


Champion who will stay: Anselmo Moreno – Should I be even more confident in Moreno now that he is a “super champion,” though I have no idea what merited his elevation by the WBA? Koki Kameda won the regular WBA title last week but I doubt a fight between the pair will get made until early 2012, giving both time to make a couple easy defenses in the interim. It also allows that fight to be hyped properly and sell out in an instant to the delight of the educated Japanese boxing crowd. Even when the pair does meet, I favor Moreno, even though the Kamedas are becoming notorious for getting favorable judging. Fernando Montiel and Joseph Agbeko are already scheduled to face red-hot young challengers in Nonito Donaire and Abner Mares, so Moreno is the natural choice since he can push off his one great challenge to next year.

Grade – A+ : Moreno rewarded my confidence in him with a dominant win over Vic Darchinyan and threw in a stoppage victory over once formidable Lorenzo Parra as well. The way Moreno defeated Darchinyan opened a lot of eyes to his talent and at age 26, the Panamanian southpaw should only get better. Signed with Golden Boy Promotions in 2011 too, which could mean as much as any win Moreno scored in the ring last year.

Champion who will go: Joseph Agbeko – I picked Fernando Montiel to lose his title in this spot last year but have slightly more confidence in Montiel than a more one-dimensional Agbeko. Please, do not get me wrong; I really like and enjoy Agbeko but just believe the style matchup favors the younger man in his fight with Abner Mares. Two fights ago, Mares would not have been ready for Agbeko but his back and forth wars with Yonnhy Perez and Vic Darchinyan steeled and prepared Mares for what is in store for him against the ultra-tough Ghanaian. Even if Agbeko does manage to get by Mares, number one challenger Vusi Malinga and a Ring magazine championship fight against the winner of the Fernando Montiel – Nonito Donaire fight are possibilities for the winter of 2011.

Grade – A : Lost to Abner Mares twice in 2011 but arguably could have beaten Mares in their first meeting had it not been for low blows and an incompetent night of refereeing. That fight demanded a rematch, where Agbeko had no answer for Mares’ versatility. Remains a top ten fighter at bantamweight and because of marketability, should get more televised fights and a title shot in the otherwise red-hot division.

Will rise in 2011: Stephane Jamoye – My toughest choice so far with the talent pool at bantamweight perhaps the deepest in all boxing. I thought about choosing Tomoki Kameda, who has an official victory over Jamoye, but he fluctuates in weight too much, fighting at junior featherweight in two of his last three fights. Besides, I thought Jamoye edged Kameda in their showdown in August and the judges scored their fight a draw (an acceptable decision), only to reverse it a couple hours later when a scoring error was “discovered.” Surprisingly, it was Jamoye who showed more ring generalship and flamboyance early and late in their fight. Jamoye did allow Kameda to fight his way into contention in the middle rounds, eating a particularly nasty hook in the fourth round and will learn to frustrate an opponent’s momentum with experience. Belgium has not created world-class fighters since the 1930s and this Jamoye kid has the attitude and chops to become the best ever from the otherwise soccer-mad nation. Outside of his loss to Kameda, Jamoye is undefeated and is the current European Union bantamweight champion at age 21. Started boxing at age 14, racking up a 56-4 amateur career, but never medaled at a major international event. Has shown a good chin and willingness to use it to throw combinations and go to the body and seems to be getting stronger as he fills out and matures. I also considered Stuart Hall from England and Los Angeles-based Russian Khabir Suleymanov but both are age 30 and that put me off selecting either. There is also Alexander “Sasha” Bakhtin, the most talented of all four, but I featured him in this spot before and his career has stagnated.

Grade – F : I should picked Tomoki Kameda, since an ambitious Jamoye lost two fights in 2011. Why Jamoye lost is admirable, traveling to England and Mexico to face tough opponents head on instead of trying to outbox physically stronger foes on their turf. Jamoye also failed to give his body time to rest from difficult fights, entering the ring six times last year. I love the kid’s ambition but it looks like Jamoye lacks the elite skills to match his determination against world-class prospects.


Champion who will stay: Toshiaki Nishioka - The 34-year-old champion has won 14 consecutive bouts, nine via stoppage, employing a slick, speedster style with unpredictable movement that adds to his stinging power. Has the eminently beatable Giovani Caro (yeah, the one knocked out by a novice Chris Avalos in 2009) as his mandatory this year and is likely to only fight twice again in 2011. There are some quality Japanese challengers but none complete enough to unseat the champ. American fans might have seen Nishioka overcome a first-round knockdown to brutally kayo (with one straight left hand) Jhonny Gonzalez in Mexico. What makes Nishioka special are nimble feet, disguising somewhat predictable punching patterns, which send him darting in every direction at the blink of an eye. Did not gain the nickname of “Speed King” for nothing and his attacking patterns are never repeated at the same angle. Nishioka has proven himself a solid champion and, despite his age, improves with every outing, partly because of his mental strength. In fact, Nishioka has not lost since 2004 and, taking his entire career into account, he should not be entirely discounted from P4P consideration.

Grade – A+ : I have to hand out highest grade possible to Nishioka, since the champion came to America and dispatched of his best challenger defeating Rafael Marquez handily. Winning in America is the one feat holier-than-though American boxing fans and insiders demand of European or Asian boxer but for some reason, do not demand American boxers do the same? Well, Nishioka did it, stepping up to the plate and hitting a homerun!

Champion who will go: Steve Molitor – I was a big supporter of Molitor early on as he impressed me with road victories in England and a multifaceted style based on speed and movement. However, Molitor might have been ruined by his stoppage loss to Celestino Caballero and even though he has been winning, it has been by the slimiest of margins. It is hard to defeat a quality fighter multiple times, which is what Molitor will have to do against Takalani Ndlovu in their third meeting this March. At 30, his southpaw advantage and speed-based game is slipping and his team is likely to take chances against an up-and-coming young gun (like the Al Haymon-managed youngster I feature next) for the right money in late 2011. A shame his loss to Caballero was so emphatic, since Molitor is the type of credible and difficult-to-beat boxer that should elevate whoever defeats him to gain the IBF throne. Instead, the new champ will be seen as having beaten a used-up champ…which I guess I am not arguing against by placing him in this spot.

Grade – A : Ndlovu reversed two previous losses to Molitor in April, furthering my thesis that Molitor was never the same after the Caballero loss in 2009. Ndlovu won every round on two judges’ cards and that had little to do with hometown scoring. Molitor did bounce back with a split decision win over Sebastien Gauthier, showing he can still earn the benefit of the doubt with an elegant boxing style. Still, at age 31, I do not expect another world title belt to be wrapped around the Canadian’s waist.

Will rise in 2011: Rico Ramos – Lots of quality boxers to choose from with last year’s surprise upstart Christopher Martin making this choice hard to argue on merit, to date. There are also Daniel Ramos and Dominican Jenifel Vicente, who defeated very tough countryman Francisco Lorenzo. Ramos gets my nod because he is an experienced amateur boxer who hooked off the jab before his tenth birthday. Rose to become 2006 PAL champ, as well as the silver medalist at the 2006 Golden Gloves and 2007 Nationals. Was considered a favorite for the Olympic team but has made the transition to the pros easy for himself with a combination of speed and well-chosen aggressiveness. Already shown his spark on “ShoBox” and ESPN telecasts, knocking out Heriberto Ruiz in sizzling fashion. In only his 12th bout, won a six-round decision over former two-weight champ Kermin Guardia but had some problems with the southpaw, failing to stop his older and smaller rival. Is said to be a hard worker in the gym (why his weight has never fluctuated above four pounds from pro debut), so he is sure to work on those finishing skills. Is rated number one by the WBA (for Ryol Lee’s title) but I am not sure he is ready for that just yet. An eliminator fight with Nehomar Cermeno could be even worse, style-wise, and is also to be avoided when Molitor could be available and Ramos is rated number five by the IBF. The talent and commitment is there but should not be rushed into the wrong title challenge in 2011.

Grade – A : I would have given an A+ but Ramos endured stretches in fights where he lacked concentration and was hit to easily on defense. Despite that, Ramos won the WBA belt from Akifumi Shimoda, struggling and needing a come-from-behind, one-punch kayo to beat the Japanese champion in America. Ramos does get credit for the difficulty of his opposition, registering a quality win over awkward Alejandro Valdez that ultimately aided Ramos in his title challenge. An excellent year by any boxing standard for a 24-year-old but it is also obvious that Ramos is far from a complete package at the highest level

You can contact Marty at or visit him at .

Subscribe to feed Subscribe to feed

© 2010 MaxBoxing UK Ltd